5.2 The Prudent Investor Rule
In response to the constraints imposed by the evolution of the prudent man standard by judicial decision, the Restatement (Third) of Trusts adopted a revised prudent investor rule. The stated purpose of the new rule was to reinvigorate the Harvard College standard:
The terms of the prudent investor rule in the new Restatement begin by returning, with modest reformulation, to the essence of the Harvard College dictum in an effort to restore that opinion’s originally intended generality and flexibility. The terms of the rule then continue in an effort to modernize trust investment law and to make its underlying principles and the relevant financial considerations more readily understandable. This was intended to discourage a repetition of earlier difficulties and temptations in application and elaboration.
The language of the rule and the accompanying commentary were thus designed to preserve the law’s adaptability. The mandates of the prudent investor rule were confined to those that seemed essential to: (i) a meaningful duty of prudence, based on its traditional elements of care, skill and caution; (ii) the protection and implementation of fiduciary goals; and (iii) supplying useful guidance to trustees, their counsel and courts, taking account of the varied needs and objectives of individual trusts and trustees.[1]
[1] Edward C. Halbach, Jr., Trust Investment Law in the Third Restatement, 77 Iowa L. Rev. 1151, 1155 (1992).
Articles
10.6 Corporations The Terms of the Trust: Extrinsic Evidence of Settlor Intent 7.5 Spendthrift Clauses and Trust Termination 6.1 Rules of Construction and Settlor Intent 1.3 The IRS Has Attempted to Derail Family Limited Partnership Planning 1.2.3 Revocable by the Grantor 7.2 Theoretical Underpinning 2.1 Attractive Attributes To Motivate Use 5.3 Maryland’s Version of the Prudent Investor Rule 3.4 Tortfeasor Access 2.3.9 Charitable Set Asides 2. State Variations 2. The Duty of Loyalty 5.4 The Last Uniform Business Entity Act That Addressed This Issue 8.3 Credible Witnesses 2.7 Deductibility of Investment Advice 4. Preserving the Assets 2. The Estate Planning Implications 4.2.2 Spousal Election 1.5.2 Durable Power of Attorney 4.3 Eliminating the Categories under the UTC and Restatement (Third) 4.6 Ascertainable Standards are Measurable 5.1 Validity in General 9.5 The UTC/Restatement Controversy 5.2.2 Not Effective Substitutes for a Broad Fiduciary Duty 3.2.2 Examples of Strict Construction 6.3 Exceptions to the Plain Meaning Rule 2. Extrinsic Evidence and the Terms of the Trust, the Plain Meaning Rule 2.1 Equity Jurisdiction for Actions Against Trustees 3.3 Enforceable Rights to Beneficiaries 3.1 Duty to Supply Copy of Trust Instrument 3.1.1 Good Faith Test 5.6 Other Spousal Property 10.1 The Privilege and the Attorney for a Trust 1.1 The “Terms of the Trust” 8.2 Dead Man’s Statute is Strictly Construed 4.1.1 The “Probate Fee” 3.3 The Nature and Form of the Accounting 2.11 Beneficiary Right to Enforcement and the Supplemental Needs Trust 3.2 The Nature and Scope of the Trustee’s Duty 5.5 Diversification and the Modern Portfolio Theory 2.9 Extended Discretion and Court Enforcement of Distributions 11.3 Transfer of Death Accounts 4.1 A Close Look at Drye and Craft 2.3 Remedies 6. Proceedings in Multiple Courts 5.1.1 The Fiduciary Obligation of Partners 3.1.2 Settlor’s Intent 6.5 Exception to Plain Meaning for Surrounding Circumstances 8.5 The Beneficiary as Trustee of Third Party Trusts 5.2 Nature of the Tenancy 8.3 Examples of Strict Construction 2.1.1 Trust Income is Taxable to the Grantor 8.1 The Maryland Dead Man’s Statute 3. The Stripping Out of Fiduciary Duty 2.5 Retaining the Categories in the Maryland Trust Code Proposal 1.3 Transfer of Death Accounts 8.2 Creditors and Limited Powers of Appointment 2.4.1 Federal Estate Tax 1.2.2 Irrevocable Trust 1.3 Contractarian Basis 2.3 “Respectable” Asset Protection Planning 7.1 The State of Mind/Intent Exception to the Hearsay Rule 7.2 Exception Covers the Declarant’s Later Action 1.3 Fiduciary Duty Generally 1.3.4 Joint Trusts/Joint Wills Issues 4.2 The Support/Discretionary Trust Distinction in Maryland 4.5 Ascertainable Standards and Estate Planning 4.2.1 Prohibiting Conduct That Frustrates the Explicit Agreement 2.3.1 The Latent Ambiguity Exception 1.2 The Importance of the Right to Information 1.3.3 Joint Trusts and Entireties Property 5.7 The Craft Case 1.1.1 An Express Trust 7.1 In General 1.3.1 Definition 1.4 Revocable Trusts 1.3.2 Revocation of Joint Trusts 1.4.1 Referred to as “Living Trusts” 5.2 Power of Attorney With the Ability to Disclaim 1.5.1 Definition 4. Bankruptcy Reform 2.1.2 Filing Requirements 12.1 Enforcement of Liens 2.2.2 The Gift From the Trust Problem Solved 2.3.6 Separate Share/65-Day Rules 2.4 The Handling of the Plain Meaning Rule Under the U.T.C. 2.3.7 Throwback Rules 1.1.5 Separation of Beneficial and Equitable Titles 2.3.8 Personal Exemptions 2.3.10 Joint Tax Return 1.1 The Origin of the Duty Owed 2.4.2 State Inheritance Tax 3.1.2 Death Before the Required Beginning Date 4.3 Creditors and General Powers of Appointment 4.2.1 Time Considerations 4.2.4 Medicaid Considerations 4.8 Extended Discretion and Court Enforcement of Distributions 4.2.5 Title Insurance 4.2.6 Maintaining Privacy 4.2.7 Planning for Disability 5.2 The Prudent Investor Rule 8.5 Opening the Door to Excluded Evidence 6.4 The Latent Ambiguity Exception 6.3 Domestic Asset Protection Trusts 1.1.6 Lack of Separation 2.3.11 Election Under IRC Sec. 645 to Treat Revocable Trusts as Part of Probate Estate 1.2 Impact of Evidentiary Rules in General 10.4 Partnership Interests in Bankruptcy 5.4 Creating or Adding to Entity Property 3.4 Traditional Trust Sense 2.8 The Rights of Remainder Beneficiaries and Ascertainable Standards 1.4.2 The Revised Uniform Partnership Act 1.2 Joint Tenancy 5.1 No Size Fits All in Estate and Asset Protection Planning 4.1 Settlor Intent: Support/Discretionary Trusts 1.1 Trust Law in General 8.3 Creditors and General Testamentary Powers of Appointment 8.1 The Maryland “General” Power 1.1.2 Whether an express trust has been created is a factual determination 2.2 Civil Conspiracy and Other Cases 3.1 “Transfer Creating the Interest” 1.1.3 Trustee and Cestui Que 2.10 Extended Discretion and the Uniform Trust Code 2.6 Powers in the Instrument 1.1 The Tax Clause as a Bequest 1.2.1 Definition 2.1 Uniform Disclaimer of Property Interests Act 2.3 The “Legal List” of Investments 4.1 Fraudulent Conveyance Look-Back Period 1.3 Maryland Common Law 1. Introduction 2.2 Medicaid 4.3 Limits on Homestead Exemption 5.3 Weakness of a Good Faith/Bad Faith Analysis 4.1 “Good Faith and Fair Dealing” 2.4 Eliminating the Categories Under the UTC and Restatement (Third) 3.1 Background 1.2.1 Common Law 5.1 The Law of Partnership Folded into the Law of Contract 8.4 Creditors and Non-Testamentary General Powers of Appointment 4.5 529 Plans 6.1 The Maryland View 3.1 Duty “To Act in Good Faith …” 1. Background 2.1 The Creditor Claim Statute 2.3.4 S Corporation Stock 2.6 Tortious Interference with an Inheritance 4.2 Not Subject to a Qualified Disclaimer 5.1.2 The Traditional Role of Fiduciary Duty in the Partnership Relationship 5.2 The 1997 Revised Uniform Partnership Act and The 2001 Revised Uniform Limited Partnership Act 4.4 Retaining the Categories Under the Maryland Trust Code Proposal 2.3.5 Flexibility as to Tax Year/ Estimated Tax Payments 3.2 QTIP Rule 5. Issues 7.3 Future Action May Include No Action 3.1 In General 1. The Historic Roots and Development of Tenancy by the Entirety 7.3 Special Status Creditors 6.7 Plain Meaning and Inter Vivos Trust 2.3.4 Regardless of the Plain Meaning Rule for Testamentary Trusts, the Plain Meaning Rule Never Applied to Inter Vivos Trusts The Estate Planning Implications of Stripping Fiduciary Duty from the Uniform Partnership Acts in Maryland and D.C. Overview of Family Limited Partnerships 3.1 The Statutory Reformation of the Traditional Dead Man’s Statute in Washington, D.C. and Virginia 11.1 The Non-Probate “Revolution” 3.2.4 Opening the Door to Excluded Evidence Estates & Trusts 101: Planning for Minor Children 8.1 In General 3.1.3 “State of Mind Not Contemplated” Standard 5. The Maryland/ D.C. Experience 8.2 Formalities of Will Substitutes 7.4 Tortfeasor Access 2. “Restatement” (Classification) 5.2.1 Limited Mandatory Rules Governing Partner Relations 4.1 General Comments 1.2 The “Terms of the Trust” 4.3 Trusts for Children 4.9 Extended Discretion and the Uniform Trust Code 2.1 Common Law Rule 9.1 Confidential Relation and the Burden of Proof 4.1 Disclaimed Property 5.3 Joint Action Necessary 4.2 The Inherently Subjective Nature of Good Faith Relevant Vocabulary 1.1 The Use of Family Limited Partnerships in Estate Planning 10.2 Management Rights; Fiduciary Obligations 11.2 Joint Tenancy 1.1.4 Efficacy of Revocable Trusts as Will Substitutes 10.5 LLCs 5. Conduct in Investing 6.2 The Plain Meaning Rule and Testamentary Trusts. 9.4 UTC Approach 10.7 Family Entities and Divorce IV. Health Care Directives 2.2 Settlor Intent: Support/Discretionary Trusts 3.2 Accountings and Revocable Trusts 1.2 The Federal Regarding the Tax Burden 2.3 The Support/Discretionary Trust Distinction in Maryland 4.1.1 Law and Economics Practitioners View 2.5 The Statutory Enumeration of Powers 4. The “New” Uniform LLC Approach: Fiduciary Duty Restored 11.4 Revocable Trusts 2.1 Introduction 3.3 Special Status Creditors 4.3 Good Faith in the Performance of the Deal 3.1.1 The Minimum Distribution Rules 3.3.2 “Misinterpretation” Or “Abuse” of Discretion 3.2.1 Required in Every Case Involving Extended Discretion 3. The Duty of Prudence Choice of Law: Tenancy by the Entirety Across State Lines 3.2.2 Only Certain Trusts to be Permitted as a Designated Beneficiary 5.5 Maryland Tenants by the Entirety Trusts 1. Overview of Fiduciary Relationships 9.1 In General 6. Movables (Accounts) 3.5 Spendthrift Clauses and Trust Termination 2.3.2 Passive Activity Loss Treatment 1. General Background 3.2 Theoretical Underpinning 1.4.3 The Contractarian Worldview 9.3 The Restatement (Third) Approach 3. Tenants by the Entirety and Bankruptcy 1.6 Fraudulent Conveyance Act 2.1 The Maryland Rule of Professional Conduct The Insolvent Estate (Select Topics from the Maryland Perspective) 1.5.3 Power of Attorney v. Trust 5.4 The Theoretical Underpinnings of the New Rule 2.6 Ascertainable Standards and Estate Planning 2.2.1 Impact Upon Creation of the Trust 6.2 Offshore Trusts 1.4 Fiduciary Duty as a Separate and Stand-Alone, Non-Contract Principle 2.1 Natural Parents Are Guardians 2.3.3 Other “Exceptions” to the Plain Meaning Rule 3.2 Reasonableness Standard 3.2 Maryland Does Not Recognize De Facto Parent Status 6.2 The Uniform Trust Code Codifies the Common Law 4.2.3 Litigation/Dispute Considerations Duties of a Personal Representative 1. Introduction 11.3.2 Standby Trusts 1.3.1 Implied Bargain 4.1 Introduction 1.1 Planning for Minor Children After the Parents’ Death 3.3.1 Family Relationship 5. Planning in Full Bar Jurisdictions: Post Judgment Transfers and/or Disclaimers in Full Bar Jurisdictions Appendix Selected Issues Regarding the Orphans Court Jurisdiction 1.4 The Maryland Uniform Estate Tax Apportionment Act 2.2 Advocate of a Contractarian View of Trusts 2.2 Under the Common Law, the Plain Meaning Rule Generally Excludes Extrinsic Evidence for Testamentary Trusts But Not for Inter Vivos Trusts 5. Movables (Tangible Property) 2.2 The Prudent Investor Act 1.5 Other Non-Probate Arrangements 6.6 Other “Exceptions” to the Plain Meaning Rule 1.6.2 The Impact of the Marketing on Responsible Planning 2.4 Statutory Powers in General 3.1 IRC § 721 (b) 1.5 The Common Law and the Codification of the Law of Trusts 5.2 Limits to Exculpatory Clauses 5.1 General Rule 2.3 Enforcement of Liens 4.2 Creditors and Limited Powers of Appointment 4.1.2 Commissions and Legal Expenses 4. Kaouris – Jurisdiction to Construe Written Documents 3.1 Grandparent Visitation Right Statute 1.5 Examples of Tax Clauses 9. Powers of a Personal Representative 3. Limited Jurisdiction – Statutory Framework 1.2 Fiduciary Duty in Law of Partnership 10.3 Proposed Changes to MRULPA 1.4 Fiduciary Standards and Trustee Identity 3. “Immovables” (Real Estate) 3.4.1 Exercise of Fiduciary Duty 2.5 The Impact of Exculpatory Clauses 1.3.2 Contract Standard of Good Faith Dealings 1.4.1 The Uniform Trust Code 11. Special Post-Mortem Issues 3.2.1 Dead Man’s Statute is Strictly Construed 3.4 Disclaimer as Transfer 2.1 Fiduciary Duty Owed by the Trustee 1.1 Asset Protection With Tenancy By The Entireties 3.2.3 A “Transaction” for Purposes of the Statute 2.2 Priority of Claims 4. Movables 10.1 The Charging Order 6.1 A Good Faith Standard within the Context of Broad Fiduciary Duty The “Terms of the Trust” Extrinsic Evidence of Settlor Intent The Intersection of Planning and Litigation Highlighting Differences Among the Jurisdictions 8.4 A “Transaction” for Purposes of the Statute 3.3 MUDOPIA 4.2 UTMA Accounts 3.1 The Nature and Scope of the Trustee’s Duty: the Johnson Decision 2.7 Ascertainable Standards are Measureable 2.3 Even with the Plain Meaning Rule Under the Common Law, There were Exceptions or “Workarounds” Around the Rule 2.4 Cost of Suit 4.1 The Maryland “General” Power 4.2 Forum Shopping 2.3.3 Other Losses During Administration 3.3.1 Settlor’s Intent 3.2 The Maryland Law 1.1 Definition of Fiduciary Duties 4.7 The Rights of Remainder Beneficiaries and Ascertainable Standards 2. Limited Jurisdiction – History 2.3.2 Exception to Plain Meaning for Surrounding Circumstances 4.4 IRAs; Insurance 5.1 The “Prudent Man Standard” 1.1 The Non-probate “Revolution” 1.2 Concept of Fair Market Value 8. Timeliness 3.2 The Maryland Dead Man’s Statute 2.1 The Common Law Rules of Construction and Settlor Intent 3.3.2 Constructive Notice of Fraud 1.1.1 Fiduciary Relations in Various Settings 3.3 Badges of Fraud 6.3 The Uniform Trust Code Permits Traditional Norms 2.3.1 In General, Section 645 Election 1.6.1 Living Trusts are Heavily Marketed 9.2 Trustee Standards 3.1 Introduction/ Basic Pattern 4.3 Disclaimer of the Survivorship Interest 3.2.1 Final Regulations 7. Duty Not to Delegate I. Estate Planning 1. Introduction 1.2.2 Economic Interest 2.2 Actions Against Trustees in General 6. Maintaining Accurate Records 4.2 The Craft Aftermath
